Summary of Yasir Qadhi's Position
In a 2021 video (Ask Shaykh YQ #252), Yasir Qadhi responds to a question from Malaysia. After a flood, a multi-faith village came together to rebuild. Muslims helped rebuild the masjid, and they participated in rebuilding homes and temples. Some objected that Muslims should not have helped rebuild the temples. Who is right?
The General Principle: Cooperation in Good
Allah says in the Quran:
"Allah does not forbid you from those who have not fought you over your religion and have not expelled you from your homes — that you be righteous toward them and act justly. Indeed, Allah loves those who act justly." (60:8)
Living in peace and harmony is one of the admirable goals of the sharia. The Prophet (ﷺ) demonstrated this repeatedly:
- He intervened to let food caravans reach the Quraysh (the enemies of the Muslims at the time) so children would not starve
- He forbade Muslims from burning date palms during the siege of Ta'if, honoring a humanitarian request from the besieged
The Red Line: Houses of Worship
However, cooperation has limits. Yasir Qadhi asks: would you help them by buying them beer? Of course not — even under a framework of kindness and cooperation, you would provide water, not alcohol. You give what you believe to be beneficial; you do not participate in what you believe to be harmful.
As Muslims, we believe that worshiping anyone other than Allah is the gravest moral error — not merely a lifestyle choice we tolerate, but something we genuinely believe is harmful for the people doing it. Therefore, actively participating in constructing or rebuilding a place of non-Muslim worship crosses the line into helping build something we consider wrong.
Yasir Qadhi's analogy: think about oppressed peoples being asked to rebuild monuments to their oppressor. If descendants of enslaved people were asked to rebuild the plantation manor or a statue honoring a slave owner, their refusal would be understood and respected. Similarly, we as Muslims have our own moral framework, and according to it, actively building shrines to other than Allah crosses a line.
How to Handle This Graciously
The key is to handle this with wisdom, kindness, and without creating unnecessary tension:
Note on Visiting or Donating
This ruling is specifically about active construction/rebuilding of places of worship. Visiting non-Muslim places of worship for social or civic purposes, or general charitable giving, is a separate matter with different scholarly opinions.