Dress & Appearance

Is wearing a necklace, earrings, or jewelry permissible for men in Islam?

Yasir Qadhi November 29, 2020 Watch on YouTube
men wearing jewelrynecklaceearringsgoldsilk

Quick Answer

Gold and silk are categorically forbidden for men by explicit prophetic prohibition — this applies to gold chains, rings, necklaces, and any silk clothing regardless of whether one is alone or in public. For non-gold jewelry like silver chains or necklaces, the ruling depends on cultural norms: the Sharia forbids men from dressing effeminately, and culture determines what counts as effeminate. In current North American culture, men wearing necklaces and earrings remains a gray area that Yasir Qadhi personally discourages but stops short of calling outright haram, noting that cultural norms are evolving.

Full Lecture Transcript (Cleaned)

The Question — 0:00

There's a question about male fashion: "Are fade haircuts allowed, and is wearing chain necklaces and rings haram for men?"

Gold and Silk Are Absolutely Forbidden for Men — 0:37

Okay, we need to have a talk. Gold necklaces? Chain necklaces — oh, not gold? Okay, still...

SubhanAllah, I don't want you to wear necklaces. That having been said, here's the point: every family has the right to negotiate, every single family has the right to discuss this and have its own rules.

From a purely fiqhi perspective: the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) did not allow men to act effeminately or dress effeminately, nor did he allow women to act or dress masculinely. This is an authentic hadith, and in fact he invoked the curse of Allah on such people.

Now that's the generic ruling. The nitty-gritty is where the controversy occurs: who gets to define what is effeminate and what is masculine?

The response is: it is culture, unless the Sharia defines it. The Sharia has defined two things as being effeminate for sure: number one, silk and number two, gold. The Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) picked up silk and gold and said:

"These two are for the women of my ummah and they're not for the men of my ummah."

So the Sharia has defined it — end of story. Any gold chain or gold ring or gold necklace or anything that is pure gold is not allowed for men to wear. Anything that is made out of silk or majority silk — whether a silk shirt, a silk jacket, a silk pant, or even a silk pajama — it doesn't matter if you're alone, you don't wear gold or silk.

When the Sharia Is Silent, Culture Defines the Ruling — 2:42

What if the Sharia hasn't made something effeminate, but the culture has made it effeminate? In this case, we follow the culture, because one of the principles of the maxims of fiqh is: where the Sharia is silent, culture will play a role (al-'ada muhakkama).

A simple example: Allah says to be kind to your parents and don't be rude to your parents. In one culture, when I was growing up, it was rude to sit with your feet facing your mother and father. In that culture, it would be haram to sit in a living room and intentionally put your feet towards your parents — because Allah has made it haram to be rude, and the culture says that sitting with your feet that way is rude.

That notion is by and large not known in the West. So if a convert or a person of Western culture were to do that, we would say that's not haram for them at all, because it's not something they know to be rude. So there is an element of culture manifesting what the Sharia has come with as a generic rule.

The Generic Rule: Men Should Act Like Men — 4:00

What is the generic rule? Men should act like men, and women should act like women. Therefore, certain things are very clear. For example, wearing skirts — generally speaking, to this day, no respectable male figure dresses in a skirt or a blouse. You can always point to that one exception that proves the rule. How do you know the rule? The rule is what respectable members of society, people considered to be paragons of virtue, people the culture looks up to — you will not find a person of repute who is male dressing in a skirt or a blouse.

The Gray Area: Earrings and Transitional Norms — 4:45

The problem comes with transitional phases. There are things that in one era are clearly not feminine, and in another era they become feminine. In one area they're not masculine, and in another area they become masculine. And there's this interim in the middle.

The classic example is earrings. When I was growing up — I remember, believe it or not, the 70s; I'm actually that old — men did not wear earrings at all. It was just not done. It began in the late 80s amongst the rap culture and people in the entertainment industry. Slowly but surely it spread to other people. But still, generally speaking, you don't find a mainstream politician or a reputable CEO of an S&P 500 company wearing earrings. Generally speaking, there's something that is considered dignified.

For example, tattoos on the face — although tattoos are haram in Islam, I'm just using it as a cultural example — it's not considered dignified even in the culture we live in. Even those who do tattoos place them on their arms and legs where they're hidden.

It's a Gray Area, Not Clearly Haram — 6:19

If somebody were to say that these days wearing a certain type of earring is considered masculine in some subcultures, they might have a point. I'm not even saying they don't — which is why it's a gray area. And which is why as well, we as Muslims should strive to maintain a dignified presence. We don't imitate people whose subcultures don't exude dignity. Generally speaking, the types of people who are dressing in these types of manners — their lifestyle in terms of drugs, alcohol, gender relations, and what they're promoting — is not something that is Islamic.

The Sharia does not want us to imitate people of ill repute. The Sharia does not want us to imitate people of the other gender. The Sharia has nobility — the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wasallam) was a noble person.

Necklaces: Not Declaring It Haram — 7:17

What you're asking about is a gray area. I can see some people saying that wearing a generic necklace is now considered masculine — I can see that, which is why I am not saying it is haram. I can see some people making that argument. That argument would not have been made 30-40 years ago. Maybe in another 30-40 years it would be the norm.

In some cultures — in Africa, for example — men do wear necklaces. Even in those cultures, the necklaces that men wear are markedly different from women's necklaces. You can look at them and recognize the difference. In that culture, if one of them were to embrace Islam, we're not going to tell him Islam requires him to get rid of his masculine necklace, because in his culture that necklace is masculine.

But in the culture that we're currently living in — North American culture — it's an ongoing process. There's an organic change taking place. And Allah knows, maybe in 30-40 years, all men will be wearing a certain type of necklace. When that happens, clearly it would not be sinful or even makruh for a man to wear that type of necklace, because that's the norm. However, as we speak — and the year is 2020 — it is not the norm, nor is it something that generally speaking people of repute do.

Personal Preference vs. Fiqh Ruling — 8:54

Also, the fact that you are my son and I have some privilege over you has a role to play as well, and I don't want my children to go down this path. And therefore — I'm very frank here — not everything that I'm not going to allow for my children am I going to say is haram. My son knows this: I have certain standards, and I'm not enforcing them on anybody else.

Me personally, I do not want my sons to do this. But to use the word haram is not something we're going to do. I'm going to say: the least that can be said is that you're opening up a door that is better to be shut at this stage. I would not want men to start wearing jewelry that is still somewhat effeminate, even though I understand that it is now the norm in some subcultures — not all, because it's not the default.

The Wristwatch Example — 9:35

The example is a wristwatch. Every man wears a watch; nobody considers it to be effeminate. Believe it or not, a hundred years ago it was considered effeminate. A hundred years ago, men had watches you pulled out of your pocket. The pocket watch was the masculine one.

This is history: the wristwatch became fashionable for men to wear only after World War I pilots. After World War I, pilots started wearing wristwatches, and of course pilots always have this aura and romanticism given to them. So then men started wearing wristwatches. Pre-World War I, there was no such thing as a wristwatch for a man — it was considered a decorative piece that only women wore. Slowly but surely, more men began to wear it, until now it is part and parcel of our culture. There are men's wristwatches and women's wristwatches.

The Core Principle — 10:30

As I said, we have to be clear here: the Sharia does not forbid an item — it forbids a concept. The concept is: men should act like men, and women should act like women. I hope that insha'Allah that answers the generic question — and Ammar, that answers your specific question as well, insha'Allah.