Islamic Practice

What happens if you make an oath in Allah's name and cannot fulfill it? What is the kaffarah?

Yasir Qadhi October 15, 2019 Watch on YouTube
oathqasamyameenkaffarahbreaking oath

Quick Answer

Invoking Allah's name in a serious oath (*yameen al-mun'aqida*) carries significant weight. If you are unable to fulfill such an oath, you must pay kaffarah: either feed 10 poor people, clothe 10 poor people, or fast 3 days. If you see a better option than what you swore, you should pursue the better option and still pay kaffarah. Using Allah's name in anger or habitually (without intention) is makruh but not haram. Intentionally lying while swearing by Allah is a major sin with no kaffarah other than sincere repentance.

Full Lecture Transcript (Cleaned)

The Serious Oath and How to Handle It — 0:18

Allah says in the Quran: Protect your oaths. (Surah al-Ma'idah 89). He says in another verse: Do not make Allah's name in your oaths a reason to avoid doing good. (Surah al-Baqarah 224) — Meaning: don't swear by Allah that you won't reconcile with your family, won't give to charity, etc.

The Context: A Common Scenario

Somebody, in a state of anger, says: "Wallahi, I will never visit that person's house again." They mean it. Then they calm down and realize reconciliation is better.

Scenario 1 — You see a better option: The Prophet (SAW) said in Bukhari and Muslim: If you swear by Allah, then you see the alternative is better — do the better option and make kaffarah for your oath. This is Allah's mercy. You are not trapped by your oath. Pursue the better choice (in this case, sulh — reconciliation), then pay kaffarah. There is no tawba required here because you are doing the better thing.

Scenario 2 — You simply cannot fulfill the oath: Life changed. Circumstances made it impossible. In this case you are 'ajiz (incapable). If it is truly beyond your control, there is no sin — but you must still make kaffarah. If you are falling short because of laziness or disinterest, then you need tawba plus kaffarah.

What Is the Kaffarah?

Allah details it in Surah al-Ma'idah, verse 89:

  • Feed 10 poor people — the average meal that you feed your own family. Not a feast, not a granola bar — the average home meal, given to 10 people.
  • OR clothe 10 poor people — average clothing comparable to what you dress your family.
  • OR free a slave — this option no longer exists in our time.
  • If you cannot afford any of the above:

  • Fast for 3 days.
  • Both options 1 and 2 are equally valid — you may choose either.

    A Warning About Using Allah's Name

    Muslims must be careful about invoking Allah's name casually: